Showing posts with label La Palma. Show all posts
Showing posts with label La Palma. Show all posts

Tuesday, 24 August 2010

PISA Under Examination: Gerry Mac Ruairc's Keynote Speech

Gerry Mac Ruairc gave a keynote speech at the symposium entitled, "Ticking the Boxes: A Critical Examination of the Process of PISA Testing from a Student Perspective."

Here are the notes from the speech:

Testing:
  • technologies of power surveillance
  • impacts of testing: high-stakes and low-stakes
Unintended consequences of policy developments:
  • what are they?
  • need to watch them
  • no one sets out to damage, but unintended consequences do that
  • alliances: neo-liberal, neo-conservative, neo-Middle class
  • accountability
  • measurement
Policy of testing in Ireland
  • began in 2008 with 7/8 year olds and 11/12 year olds
  • results not centrally collated - within schools
  • reviewed during Whole School Inspection
  • must report scores to parents
  • vertical system of testing
  • 15 year olds and 18 year olds subject to more standardized testing
  • TIMSS, PIRLS, PISA
Ireland
  • small schools
  • 8 schools have less than 50 students, 291 schools had greater than 500 students, and 238 students had 300-499 students.
  • voluntary secondary schools in Ireland: privately owned, charge fees but publicly funded, Catholic or the Church of Ireland
  • community and comprehensive schools
  • vocational schools with a working class profile
General trends:
  • commitment to knowledge economy
  • commitment to education
Ireland in PISA:
  • above average in math and science
  • 5th or 6th place in reading
PISA 2006 Ireland:
  • 165 schools randomly selected
  • mix from different schools, e.g. secondary, vocational
  • 4585 students
  • 5 different grades (Irish 1-5)
  • high level of agreement to participate
  • Reading Literacy Level 1 or below: 12.2% (OECD average: 20.1%)
  • Science Literacy Level 1 or below: 15.3%
Socio-economic groups and testing:
  • language and linguistic discontinuity
  • choice of language use intended or unintended?
  • social class achievement in PISA: working class - lower achievement, middle class - higher achievement
  • curriculum vs. culture
  • multiple-choice answers - linguistic choices of the working class
Research on PISA 2009 - "PISA girls"
  • disadvantaged, inner-city girls
  • "opportunistic" sampling
  • didn't know what the test was looking for
  • Principal talked about the timing and the intensity of the process
  • school PISA coordinator talked of "students wilting," "too intense" process, "what monster is this feeding," "rat in a lab" scenario
  • ticking the boxes just to "get rid of it"
  • girls' view - upset by answering questionnaires about lifestyle
  • impact on engagement - interested at first, but then just ticking boxes
  • issues of confidentiality - names of booklets
  • didn't try as hard because of not getting results back
  • the need for calculators - five grade levels in the room. Students were too embarrassed to ask for calculators
  • personal nature of items on questionnaires: too "nosy," felt swayed by the socio-economic nature of questions
  • negative sense of self: not willing to write about their parents' professions, some lied, bias of jobs listed for parents - not "normal" jobs in a deprived area
Conclusion:
  • need to engage with student perspectives on the testing process
  • need to dig deeper an enrich our understanding of socio-economic level
  • need to consider the impact of socio-economic status

PISA Under Examination: Tom Popkewitz's Keynote Speech

Tom Popkewitz gave a keynote speech entitled, "PISA - Numbers, Standardizing Conduct, and the Alchemy of School Subjects"

The notes from his speech are as follows:

A content/context-free test is an illusion.

The Practical Knowledge of PISA helps us "see" historical assemblages and cultural theses about modes of life. It is like a recipe. Ingredients lead to a final product. PISA does not see the "ingredients." It is seen as a whole, but knowledge is not practical. PISA has become a cultural phenomenon, it is talked about and acted upon.

The Reason of PISA - Transnational Governance, National Salvation, and the Political Numbers as a Telling truth. Here, numbers are an important part of social science. "Facts" are uniform, objective, and rigorous. Democracy has a correlation with measurement. There is a paradox of numbers: they appear as fact through the making of that fact.

Numbers and Assessment in Making Equivalences: Global Positioning Systems. PISA monitors student improvement and student performance. A GPS always knows its position. Constant measurement and performance helps locate oneself in the world (Simons) and gives navigational tools (Lindblad). This does not act directly on people.

PISA: The Alchemy and School Subjects. "The alchemy" is an analogy to medieval practices to think about pedagogical translations. PISA has little relation to interaction and communication of the academic fields. The "practical knowledge" assembles a cultural thesis about the "lifelong learner," a mode of life who the child is and should be.

PISA as Cultural Thesis of the Lifelong Learner: Who Made the Recipe of Practical Knowledge? A lifelong learner is flexible, active, and collaborative. An uncertain world needs problem solving. This works in a global world with no finishing line. Life continues responsibly. The only choice is to choose.

Science: has textbooks to emphasize greater participation and problem solving to learn the symbolic systems of science.
Mathematics: has modeling and predicting of real-world phenomena
Disciplinary knowledge: stable, logical, and analytic structures separated from the social and cultural fields in its production.
Scientific Literacy: no consensus across countries. It is NOT a universal language (in textbooks)

PISA, School Subjects, and Historical Context: The Planning of Science in the Redemption of Society. Science uses the future to reorganize the present. 19th century science went from the mastery of the physical world to the mastery of the social world. Science as planning: it was to predict the future.

PISA and the "Reason" of Practical Knowledge: Exclusion and Abjections in the Impulse to Include. Alchemy: double gestures -- hope for the future and fears of dangers. Education for all: "all" assumes a unity and a consensus. "All" erases differences and the inscription of psychological and social differences.

Conclusions.
I. PISA is not merely measures of practical knowledge of the future. What is practical knowledge? There are different contexts.

II. The politics of school.
  • Alchemy: knowing occurs as "practical."
  • Installation of "shepherds" to guide what is "practical."
  • PISA: hope for the future, the dangers, and dangerous of populatoins.
III. The limits of the present.

IV. Historical situations: thinking about the present with implications and consequences.

PISA Under Examination: Changing Knowledge, Changing Tests, and Changing Schools (Part Two)

The CESE Symposium held on the island of La Palma also hosted a poster exhibition. These are the posters presented at the Symposium:
  • A Portrait of European Top Performers in Science by Fabio Alivernini, Laura Palmerio, Valerie Tortora, National Institute for the Evaluation fo the Education System, Frascati, Italy
  • Thinking About PISA and the Participation of the Parents by Claudio Almonacid Aguila, Ana Jimenez Saldana, Daniel Rios Munoz, University of Santiago de Chile
  • An Investigation of Reasons for Finland's Success in PISA by Jennifer H. Chung, Liverpool Hope University
  • From the Static to the Dynamic: PISA Items as an Educational Resource by Jose R. Galo Sanchez, Descrtes Project, Institute of Education Technologies, Ministry of Education, Spain; University of Cordoba
  • PISA, Finland and the Autonomous Community of Madrid by Maria Jose Garcia Ruiz, UNED
  • Digital Skills Appear in PISA Report: Are Students and Teachers Prepared? by Ana Garcia-Valcarcel, Francisco Javier Tejedor, Anunciacion Quintero, University of Salamanca
  • Difference of Gender in the Educative Practices and Expectations of Students by Carmen Nieves Perez Sanchez, Moises Betancort, University of La Laguna
  • PISA on Front Page by Ariadne Runte-Geidel, Diego Sevilla, University of Grenada
  • The Educational and Sociolabour Guidance Program: An Instrument to Facilitate the Sociolabour Transition by Lidia E. Santana Vega, Jose A Santana Lorenzo, University of La Laguna
  • Similarities and Differences Between Spanish and Finnish Teachers: Organization of School Time and Space, Selection and Salary by Begona Zamora Fortuny, University of La Laguna
  • The New Challenges Posted by PISA for a Graduate Programme in Upper Secondary Education Teaching at the National Autonomous University of Mexico by Juan F. Zorilla, UNAM, Mexico

PISA Under Examination: Changing Knowledge, Changing Tests, and Changing Schools

The Comparative Education Society in Europe (CESE) held in international symposium in La Palma, Canary Islands, Spain from the 23rd to the 26th of November 2009. This was organized by Miguel A. Pereyra, President of CESE and Professor of Comparative Education at the University of Granada.

The Symposium featured these Keynote Speakers:
  • David C. Berliner of Arizona State University
  • Antonio Bolivar of the University of Grenada
  • Julio Carabana of the Complutense University of Madrid
  • Robert Cowan of the Institute of Education, University of London
  • Ulf P. Lundgren of the University of Uppsala
  • Katharina Maag Merki of the University of Zurich
  • Gerry Mac Ruairc of University College Dublin
  • Clara Morgan of Carleton University
  • Donatella Palomba of the University of Rome "Tor Vergata"
  • Anselmo Roberto Paolone of the University of Rome "Tor Vergata"
  • Thomas S. Popkewitz of the University of Wisconsin - Madison
  • Javier Salinas of the Complutense University of Madrid
  • David Scott of the Institute of Education, University of London
  • Daniel Santin of the Complutense University of Madrid
  • Hannu Simola of the University of Helsinki
  • Petra Stanat of the Freie Universitat Berlin
  • Daniel Troehler of the University of Luxembourg